-
no more shitty leftist streamer discourse. only more high guardian spice
-
episode 2 @__MoBlack/1459414006951776258
-
If you ever wanted to know what my note-taking process for anime essays is, it's mostly this, except in a Google doc instead of on Twitter, and I save the screencaps to a flash drive instead of uploading them here
-
it's buffering hold on I will say I have had subtitles on the whole time and they haven't showed up. Other languages like French work, but I'd like to be able to watch in English with subtitles
-
Okay we're back. So here's my thing right? The lack of conflict in the story makes it hard to get invested i the idea of becoming a guardian. We know Rosemary's mom was a guardian, and that being a guardian is dangerous, but we haven't been shown a world *in need of guardians*
-
We haven't seen poverty in any real sense, or unjust systems, no monsters invading from the north, or violent groups that threaten the innocent. We're *told* that being a guardian is deadly but not from what.
-
We're seeing these kids train to be guardians and I still don't know what that means. The show is explaining in very literal terms what that means (a dangerous job with a huge amount of responsibility), but not what it means narratively
-
fuck now my computer's not taking screenshots sorry
-
So I'm realizing that a lot of these tweets have been negative but I wanted to confirm I'm having a fine time
-
I was kidding about the fucked your mom thing but he literally said she was "fierce" they fucked
-
it's not even worth explaining how the cat got like that just roll with it okay?
-
So we're getting to the scene where the dude says he's trans, which is one of exactly two HGS scenes I've seen before watching the show
-
whether or not it's "good" or "bad" "representation" I will table as a question for now, especially since trans people made this show and trans is something of which I am not. But in context this scene is rather interesting
-
Because, up until now there has been very little conflict or adversity in this world. Everything is more or less idyllic and perfect. All the adults are nice and wise. There is some amount of social stratification between rural and urban, old and new, but it's minimal
-
So it is really interesting to me as a decision that in a world devoid of adversity, a trans person would still have to take the magical equivalent of HRT monthly to keep the body that they want. Does this make sense? Having to split these tweets for length is annoying but
-
Like the chose to play fast and loose with every hardship and adversity that exists in the real world. Magic and good will fix most of the problems we would have here... with the exception of trans people, for which the medical process for transitioning is identical to real life
-
we'll pin this it seems important
-
her mom left school grounds without permission... to have sex. we all know it's true
-
So I do have time for maybe one more episode before it'll get really irresponsible work-wise. I think the vibe I've sorta centered in on is something like "someone made the show they wish they had growing up"
-
It's very "here's what healthy relationships look like" and "here's how to deal with feeling like you need to live up to something" and "here's an introduction to being trans that doesn't immediately other you" and so on, which can explain why it feels so... squishy, na mean?